“我们不是美国”:澳大利亚政界商界称民众抵制 AI 数据中心是受美国舆论影响We Are Not America”: Australian Political and Business Circles Say Public Opposition to AI Data Centers Is Influenced by American Public Opinion


AI free token/AI免费积分

IT之家 9 月 27 日消息,据卫报报道,澳大利亚政界和商界人士认为,当地民众对 AI 数据中心日益增长的不满情绪,很大程度上是从美国“输入”而来的,并不能完全反映澳大利亚本土的实际情况。

“我们不是美国”:澳大利亚政界商界称民众抵制 AI 数据中心是受美国舆论影响

IT之家注意到,与美国类似,随着大规模 AI 数据中心建设加速,澳大利亚一些社区对这类项目的抵触情绪也在不断增加。不过,兼容数据中心建设的政府官员和企业高管认为,澳大利亚的数据中心建设规模更小,监管也更加严格,因而对当地环境和社会造成的影响远低于美国。他们表示,美国国内围绕数据中心展开的激烈争论,借助社交媒体传播到澳大利亚,正在加剧当地的负面情绪。

去年美国开始浮现针对数据中心的大规模反对浪潮时,这股情绪在澳大利亚还比较有限。但到了 2026 年,相关争议已经迅速演变成全国性话题,并引发了要求暂停全国数据中心建设的呼声、社区抗议活动以及 3 项政府调查。与此同时,澳大利亚各州正在制定相关框架,联邦政府也开始着手制定数据中心建设以及能源、水资源使用维度的规则。

澳大利亚各州政府都在寻求经济增长,因而总体上对新数据中心带来的投资持欢迎态度。有些项目规模巨大,甚至促使州政府绕过地方议会原本的审批流程。

今年 7 月,时任维多利亚州经济增长部长史蒂夫 · 迪莫普洛斯(Steve Dimopoulos)曾表示,从数据中心数量来看,维多利亚州仅次于新南威尔士州,而且新数据中心的增长速度已经超过澳大利亚人口最多的新南威尔士州。他表示,民众对新开发项目的不满情绪日益高涨,这是受美国社交媒体影响的结果。

他说:“笔者看到美国一些州正在考虑禁止新的大型数据中心,而美国当地的相关运动以及大型项目正在影响澳大利亚的公众舆论。因为当这些内容浮现在你的手机上时,你会觉得它就在身边,或者认为类似情况可能很快就会来到这里。”

这位部长还表示:“笔者不是美国。笔者的规划、能源和水资源体系受到更加严格的监测、管理和监管。”

数据中心行业的负责人同样对这股反弹情绪表示不满,认为相关讨论存在误导性,而且缺乏事实依据。

数据中心行业主要游说组织 Data Centres Australia 负责人贝琳达 · 丹尼特(Belinda Dennett)今年 3 月在一次演讲中表示:“澳大利亚的数据中心争论,是建立在美国数据基础上的。”

丹尼特称,普通民众对数据中心的反应从好奇、困惑到恐惧不等,而媒体对这一行业的报道“令人担忧”。她说:“这个行业被描述成能源吸血鬼、用水大户和就业杀手。难题在于,其中大多数新闻标题都源自美国,而美国的数据中心行业规模完全不同,所处的市面规则也完全不同。这些说法被原封不动地移植到澳大利亚的讨论中,仿佛两国的情况完全可以相互比较。”

丹尼特表示,美国具备 5400 座数据中心,总容量达到 53.7GW;相比之下,澳大利亚具备 252 座数据中心,总容量为 1.4GW。不过,美国数据中心数量的统计结果在不同来源之间存在差异。

她说:“当人们看到数据中心给电网带来压力、推高电费并消耗大量水资源的报道时,他们看到的是美国面临的难题,却未经分析就将这些难题套用到了澳大利亚市面,而两者几乎没有可比性。”

不过,丹尼特没有提到的是,澳大利亚人口约 2800 万,当下平均每 10 万人具备不到 1 座数据中心;美国人口约 3.427 亿,平均每 10 万人具备约 1.5 座数据中心。

与此同时,澳大利亚的数据中心建设正在迅速提速。当下已有多个容量达到 1GW 甚至更高的大型数据中心处于规划阶段。

TikTok 和 Instagram 上的热门视频也开始集中讨论当地社区对这些项目的担忧,其中涵盖计划建设在墨尔本外围、容量达到 2.4GW 的数据中心,以及位于北领地、计划使用燃气供电、容量达到 2GW 的数据中心。

悉尼大学数字政策教授兼高级研究员罗布 · 尼科尔斯(Rob Nicholls)表示,2GW 相当于约 200 万户家庭一年的用电量。而北领地总人口仅略高于 26.5 万人。

澳大利亚政府注意到了美国因数据中心电力需要增长而带动天然气行业扩张的情况,因而计划绕过州政府权限,禁止使用天然气为数据中心供电。

依据拟议的新规则,数据中心运营商必须向电力平台新增相当于其自身用电量的可再生能源供应。

不过,也有一些专家认为,澳大利亚民众参考美国的情况对数据中心提出质疑是合理的。

尼科尔斯表示:“来自美国社交媒体的声音格外强烈,而且背后有合理的逻辑:‘它会提高电价,也会提高水价,而我得不到任何好处。’这是一种合理的立场。”

尼科尔斯认为,澳大利亚政府面临的难题,是向民众解释美国所面对的难题与澳大利亚当地的难题究竟存在怎样的差异。

相关监管框架的立法工作预计要到明年才会推进,这也促使一些人呼吁澳大利亚效仿纽约州,在正式规则出台之前暂停新的数据中心项目。

在此之前,澳大利亚当下已经有两项州级调查和一项联邦调查正在审查数据中心行业,同时新的项目申请仍在不断增加,并持续引发当地居民的反对。

澳大利亚许多数据中心由美国企业所有。澳大利亚联邦政府工艺助理部长安德鲁 · 查尔顿(Andrew Charlton)表示,由于运营这些设施的许多企业并非澳大利亚公司,当地民众可能因而对数据中心项目持怀疑态度。

微软和亚马逊已经运营多个数据中心,而 OpenAI 和 Anthropic 也正在考虑在澳大利亚建设自己的数据中心。

查尔顿本周在一次演讲中表示:“仅仅在澳大利亚建设数据中心,并不意味着澳大利亚就能取得 AI 产业带来的经济利益。笔者可以给出土地,可以给出电力,可以托管这些机器,但最终仍可能发现,大部分价值以及大量经济收益都流向了海外。”

查尔顿呼吁,希望在澳大利亚建设数据中心的企业可以以优惠条件,为澳大利亚初创企业、研究人员和非营利组织给出计算资源。他还提出,澳大利亚可以基于开放权重模型构建本土 AI 能力。

查尔顿警告称:“笔者可能最终会变得依赖进口的智能本身。”

本文来源:https://www.ithome.com/1/007/481.htm
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

IT Home reported on September 27 that, according to The Guardian, Australian political and business figures believe growing dissatisfaction among local residents with AI data centers is largely "imported" from the United States and does not fully reflect local Australian conditions.

We Are Not America”: Australian Political and Business Circles Say Public Opposition to AI Data Centers Is Influenced by American Public Opinion

IT Home noted that, similar to the United States, as large-scale AI data center construction accelerates, some Australian communities are increasingly opposing such projects. However, government officials and corporate executives who support data center construction believe that Australia's data center projects are smaller and more strictly regulated, so their impact on the local environment and society is far lower than in the United States. They say heated debates in the United States over data centers, spread through social media to Australia, are exacerbating local negative sentiment.

Last year, when a large wave of opposition to data centers first emerged in the United States, that sentiment remained relatively limited in Australia. But by 2026, the controversy had rapidly become a national issue, triggering calls for a nationwide pause on data center construction, community protests, and three government inquiries. Meanwhile, Australian states are developing relevant frameworks, and the federal government has begun drafting rules covering data center construction and energy and water use.

State governments across Australia are seeking economic growth and therefore generally welcome the investment brought by new data centers. Some projects are so large that they have led state governments to bypass local councils' original approval processes.

In July this year, then Victorian Minister for Economic Growth Steve Dimopoulos said that, in terms of the number of data centers, Victoria is second only to New South Wales, and that the growth of new data centers has already outpaced New South Wales, Australia's most populous state. He said rising public dissatisfaction with new development projects was the result of the influence of US social media.

He said: "We are seeing some US states considering banning new large data centers, and the movements and large projects in the United States are influencing Australian public opinion. Because when this content appears on your phone, you feel it is close by, or you think a similar situation could soon come here."

The minister also said: "We are not the United States. Our planning, energy, and water systems are subject to stricter monitoring, management, and regulation."

Leaders in the data center industry are likewise unhappy with the backlash, saying the discussion is misleading and lacks factual basis.

Belinda Dennett, head of Data Centres Australia, the industry's main lobbying organization, said in a speech in March this year: "Australia's data center debate is built on US data."

Dennett said ordinary residents' reactions to data centers range from curiosity and confusion to fear, while media coverage of the industry is "worrying." She said: "The industry is described as an energy vampire, a heavy water user, and a job killer. The challenge is that most of these headlines originate from the United States, whose data center industry is of a completely different scale and operates under completely different market rules. These claims are transplanted intact into the Australian debate, as if the situations in the two countries are perfectly comparable."

Dennett said the United States has 5,400 data centers with a total capacity of 53.7GW; by comparison, Australia has 252 data centers with a total capacity of 1.4GW. However, figures for the number of US data centers vary among sources.

She said: "When people see reports that data centers strain the power grid, push up electricity prices, and consume large amounts of water, they are seeing the problems facing the United States, yet they apply those problems to the Australian market without analysis, even though the two are barely comparable."

But what Dennett did not mention is that Australia has a population of about 28 million, with fewer than one data center per 100,000 people on average; the United States has a population of about 342.7 million, with about 1.5 data centers per 100,000 people.

Meanwhile, data center construction in Australia is rapidly accelerating. Several large data centers with capacities of 1GW or more are already in the planning stage.

Popular videos on TikTok and Instagram have also begun to focus on local community concerns about these projects, including a planned 2.4GW data center on the fringe of Melbourne and a planned 2GW data center in the Northern Territory that would use gas for power.

Rob Nicholls, professor of digital policy and senior researcher at the University of Sydney, said 2GW is equivalent to the annual electricity use of about 2 million households. The total population of the Northern Territory is only slightly above 265,000.

The Australian government has noticed that in the United States, expansion of the natural gas industry has been driven by increased electricity demand from data centers, and therefore plans to bypass state government authority to prohibit gas-powered data centers.

Under the proposed new rules, data center operators must add renewable energy supply to the power grid equivalent to their own electricity consumption.

However, some experts believe it is reasonable for Australians to question data centers by referencing the situation in the United States.

Nicholls said: "The voices coming from US social media are especially strong, and there is a logical reason behind them: 'It will raise electricity prices and also raise water prices, and I get no benefit.' That is a reasonable position."

Nicholls believes the challenge for the Australian government is to explain to the public how the problems facing the United States differ from the problems faced locally in Australia.

Legislative work on the relevant regulatory framework is not expected to advance until next year, prompting some calls for Australia to follow New York State by pausing new data center projects before formal rules are introduced.

Before that, Australia already has two state-level inquiries and one federal inquiry examining the data center industry, while new project applications continue to increase and continue to provoke opposition from local residents.

Many data centers in Australia are owned by US companies. Andrew Charlton, Assistant Minister for Industry in the Australian federal government, said that because many companies operating these facilities are not Australian firms, local residents may therefore be skeptical of data center projects.

Microsoft and Amazon already operate multiple data centers, while OpenAI and Anthropic are also considering building their own data centers in Australia.

Charlton said in a speech this week: "Simply building data centers in Australia does not mean Australia can capture the economic benefits brought by the AI industry. We can provide land, we can provide electricity, we can host these machines, but in the end we may still find that most of the value and a large share of the economic gains flow overseas."

Charlton urged companies hoping to build data centers in Australia to provide computing resources to Australian startups, researchers, and nonprofits on favorable terms. He also proposed that Australia could build domestic AI capability based on open-weight models.

Charlton warned: "We may ultimately become dependent on imported intelligence itself."

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry