微软员工为 Copilot 辩护:没人用的印象来自旧金山科技泡沫Microsoft employee defends Copilot: The impression that nobody uses it comes from the San Francisco tech bubble


AI free token/AI免费积分

IT之家 9 月 27 日消息,据 Windows Latest 报道,微软首席执行官萨提亚 · 纳德拉(Satya Nadella)宣布 Copilot 迎来迄今规模最大的更新,甚至将其称为“面向工作的全新操作平台”后,一条略带嘲讽意味的评论迅速取得了 20 万次浏览。

“认真问一句:到底有谁在用 Copilot?”一名开发者关系工程师发问。

微软员工为 Copilot 辩护:没人用的印象来自旧金山科技泡沫

通常情况下,这类评论不会得到微软维度的回应,因为微软很清楚,在这种争论中很难占到便宜。不过,这次新版 Copilot 的潜力似乎足够大,一名微软员工确实认真回应了这一难题。

微软员工为 Copilot 辩护:没人用的印象来自旧金山科技泡沫

“认真回答:有人在用。”微软员工尼古拉斯 · 布斯塔曼特(Nicolas Bustamante)写道。他认为,“没人使用 Copilot”的说法,源于一些人长期生活在旧金山科技圈的“科技泡沫”中。

IT之家注意到,他还给出了数据作为佐证:Microsoft 365 Copilot 当下已经具备超过 3000 万个付费席位。

不过,这个数字并不是重点。他解释称,大型企业客户的需要,与一名每天刷 X 平台的初创公司员工完全不同。

微软员工:离开旧金山科技圈后,Copilot 的情况完全不同

布斯塔曼特在微软于 2026 年 4 月收购其 AI 金融研究初创公司 Fintool 后加入微软。在个人网站上,他将当下的工作描述为带领一个团队,“构建可以理解使用者工作、在后台运行,并在使用者提出要求之前主动完成任务的 AI 智能体”。

这听起来恰好与 Autopilot 的定位高度相似,Autopilot 是 Copilot 新增的一项类似 OpenClaw 的智能体能力。

事实上,布斯塔曼特转发并评论那条帖子,并不是想与评论者争个高下,而是想解释为什么尽管 Copilot 遭到大量批评,仍然具备如此多的付费使用者。

“加入微软之前,我认识的大概只有 5 个人使用 Copilot。我生活在旧金山的科技圈里,笔者所有人所在的公司员工数量都不到 5000 人。”

他的观点是,X 平台上的科技和 AI 相关讨论,很大程度上由初创公司创始人、开发者以及小型企业员工主导。但大型企业需要的东西完全不同。

用他的话说:“大型企业需要可以与现有数据协同工作的 AI,同时满足隐私和合规要求,而且往往还要覆盖多个国家。再加上政府机构和受到监管的行业,情况就更加复杂。Copilot 可以处理这些难题。”

微软显然并没有最强的聊天机器人。但微软销售的是与聊天机器人深度整合的身份管理、权限控制和合规能力,而对于一家银行的法务团队来说,这些能力可能比最新的 Claude 模型有多强更加关键。

布斯塔曼特还提到了自己的日常使用方式:“使用 Copilot CLI 开展编程(可以调用 Gemini、OpenAI、xAI 和 Anthropic 的模型!),日常聊天则使用 Copilot Cowork。”

当然,具体可以使用哪些模型取决于使用者的套餐和组织政策,并不是所有 Copilot 使用者都可以随意调用上述四家 AI 公司的模型。不过,这也表明微软已经不再强调自己的模型一定是最好的,而是采取了“你挑选模型,笔者给出统一入口”的策略。

3000 万个付费席位,不等于 3000 万人每天打开 Copilot

微软在今年 7 月的财报电话会议上确认了 3000 万个付费席位这一数字,同时表示 Copilot 当下的每周使用情况已经达到与 Outlook 和 Teams 相当的水平。

不过,一个付费席位只能说明企业购买了相应许可证,并不能说明取得许可证的人究竟每周打开 Copilot 一次,还是从来没有使用过。

布斯塔曼特的评论区很快就有人指出了这一点。一名使用者问道:“我的工作单位算是为它付费了,但我根本不用。那么我的席位也算在这 3000 万里面吗?”

另一条评论写道:“人们之所以‘使用’它,是因为它被集成进 Office 里。实际上没人真正使用它。”

还有人认为这个数据“可能是这里最糟糕的统计口径”,并表示自己在员工数量为 50 至 100 人的公司里工作多年,“从没见过有人真正使用它”。

还有一条评论尤其值得注意,它把 Copilot 比作另一个微软机型:“Copilot 就是 AI 领域的 Teams。人们使用它,是因为雇主花钱买了那些包含 Azure 和 Office 在内的漂亮企业套餐,他们根本没有挑选。”

Windows Latest 对此也有类似观点:Teams 之所以被使用,很大程度上是因为它被捆绑进企业服务,并且往往是必须使用的机型。它更像是一个被企业接受的工具,而不是一个真正受到使用者喜爱的机型。

当然,这些都只是个人观点,布斯塔曼特的说法同样如此。不过,Windows Latest 今年 7 月报道称,在推出三年后,Microsoft 365 Copilot 的使用率仍低于 4.5%,每周打开 Copilot 的使用者比例只有 1%。

Copilot 长期遭遇的质疑,解释了为什么 X 平台上很多人认为没人使用它

Windows 上的 Copilot 已经经历了太多次形态变化,以至于很难完整梳理其发展过程:最初是侧边栏,随后变成原生 WinUI 应用。今年 4 月,它又悄悄捆绑了完整的 Microsoft Edge,导致其空闲状态下的内存占用从不到 100MB 一路升至最高约 1GB。

另外,微软在 2025 年还将 Copilot 塞进了 Windows 11 的几乎每个角落,到了 2026 年又意识到这一做法存在难题,并将其从记事本、截图工具等多个应用中移除。

甚至连品牌名称都变得混乱。就在纳德拉宣布新版 Copilot 的前一天,微软还将 Microsoft 365 Copilot 和 Copilot 两个社交媒体账号开展了合并。

因而,一个使用者如果接触 Copilot 的经历只是 Office 里一个不需要的按钮,或者一个占用大量内存的网页应用,那么他对 Copilot 的看法,自然会与一名使用 Copilot 搜索公司文件、同时受到完善权限控制的企业员工截然不同。

微软押注新版 Copilot 弥合这一差距

至于 3000 万个付费席位究竟有多少真正被使用,如今或许已经不再是最关键的难题。因为新版 Copilot 为微软给出了一个更充分的理由,让更多使用者真正打开这款应用。

新版 Copilot 的 Home 页面整合了 Chat 和 Cowork 能力;Code 允许使用者使用自然语言创建小型应用;Autopilot 即使使用者退出登录后仍能继续工作;Word、Excel 和 PowerPoint 也都被整合进 Copilot 应用。

微软员工为 Copilot 辩护:没人用的印象来自旧金山科技泡沫

坦率地说,与过去长期被嘲讽为“Clippy 2.0”的 Copilot 相比,这一次微软提出的机型定位要大得多。

布斯塔曼特想表达的是,确实已经有人在使用 Copilot 完成实际工作,只是这些人并不是每天在 X 平台上讨论它的人。

而纳德拉此次推出的全新 Copilot 超级应用,则是微软试图让更多人真正做到这一点,无论他们是否身处旧金山科技圈。

本文来源:https://www.ithome.com/1/007/466.htm
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

IT Home reported on September 27 that, according to Windows Latest, after Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella announced the largest update to Copilot yet, even calling it "a brand-new operating platform for work," a slightly mocking comment quickly gained 200,000 views.

"Serious question: who is actually using Copilot?" asked a developer relations engineer.

Microsoft employee defends Copilot: The impression that nobody uses it comes from the San Francisco tech bubble

Normally, this kind of comment would not get a response from Microsoft, because Microsoft knows it is hard to gain the upper hand in such arguments. However, the potential of the new Copilot seems big enough this time, and a Microsoft employee did seriously respond to this question.

Microsoft employee defends Copilot: The impression that nobody uses it comes from the San Francisco tech bubble

"Serious answer: someone is using it." Microsoft employee Nicolas Bustamante wrote. He believes that the claim that "no one uses Copilot" stems from some people living long-term in the "tech bubble" of the San Francisco tech scene.

IT Home noted that he also provided data as evidence: Microsoft 365 Copilot currently has over 30 million paid seats.

However, that number is not the point. He explained that the needs of large enterprise customers are completely different from those of a startup employee who scrolls X every day.

Microsoft employee: After leaving the San Francisco tech bubble, the situation with Copilot is completely different

Bustamante joined Microsoft after Microsoft acquired his AI financial research startup Fintool in April 2026. On his personal website, he describes his current job as leading a team that "builds AI agents that can understand the user's work, run in the background, and proactively complete tasks before the user asks."

That sounds highly similar to Autopilot's positioning, as Autopilot is a new OpenClaw-like agent capability added to Copilot.

In fact, Bustamante did not share and comment on that post to argue with the commenter, but to explain why Copilot still has so many paying users despite receiving a lot of criticism.

"Before joining Microsoft, I only knew about 5 people who used Copilot. I live in the San Francisco tech circle, and everyone I know works at companies with fewer than 5,000 employees."

His view is that tech and AI discussions on X are largely dominated by startup founders, developers, and small business employees. But large enterprises need something completely different.

In his words: "Large enterprises need AI that can work with existing data while meeting privacy and compliance requirements, and often covering multiple countries. Add government agencies and regulated industries, and the situation becomes even more complex. Copilot can handle these challenges."

Microsoft clearly does not have the strongest chatbot. But Microsoft sells identity management, permission control, and compliance capabilities that are deeply integrated with the chatbot, and for a bank's legal team, these capabilities may be more critical than how strong the latest Claude model is.

Bustamante also mentioned his own daily usage: "Using Copilot CLI for coding (which can call models from Gemini, OpenAI, xAI, and Anthropic!) and using Copilot Cowork for daily chat."

Of course, which models can be used depends on the user's plan and organizational policy, and not all Copilot users can freely call models from those four AI companies. However, this also shows that Microsoft no longer emphasizes that its own model is the best, but has adopted a strategy of "you pick the model, we provide a unified entry point."

30 million paid seats do not equal 30 million people opening Copilot every day

Microsoft confirmed the 30 million paid seats figure during its earnings call in July this year, while also stating that Copilot's weekly usage is now on par with Outlook and Teams.

However, a paid seat only means the enterprise has purchased the corresponding license, and does not indicate whether the person with the license opens Copilot once a week or never uses it.

Someone in Bustamante's comments quickly pointed this out. A user asked: "My workplace pays for it, but I don't use it. So does my seat count in that 30 million?"

Another comment wrote: "People 'use' it because it's integrated into Office. Actually no one really uses it."

Another person thought the figure "might be the worst metric here" and said that after working for years at companies with 50 to 100 employees, "I've never seen anyone actually use it."

One comment in particular is worth noting, as it compared Copilot to another Microsoft product: "Copilot is the Teams of the AI world. People use it because employers paid for those fancy enterprise bundles that include Azure and Office, and they have no choice."

Windows Latest also holds a similar view: Teams is used largely because it is bundled into enterprise services and is often a mandatory product. It is more like a tool accepted by enterprises rather than a product truly loved by users.

Of course, these are all personal opinions, as is Bustamante's statement. However, Windows Latest reported in July this year that after three years of launch, Microsoft 365 Copilot's usage rate is still below 4.5%, and only 1% of users open Copilot weekly.

The long-standing skepticism about Copilot explains why many people on X think no one uses it

Copilot on Windows has gone through so many form changes that it is hard to fully trace its evolution: it started as a sidebar, then became a native WinUI app. In April this year, it quietly bundled the full Microsoft Edge, causing its idle memory usage to jump from under 100MB all the way up to about 1GB.

Additionally, in 2025 Microsoft stuffed Copilot into almost every corner of Windows 11, and by 2026 realized this approach had problems and removed it from multiple apps such as Notepad and Snipping Tool.

Even the brand name has become confusing. Just one day before Nadella announced the new Copilot, Microsoft merged the social media accounts of Microsoft 365 Copilot and Copilot.

Therefore, if a user's only exposure to Copilot is an unnecessary button in Office or a memory-hungry web app, their view of Copilot will naturally be very different from that of an enterprise employee who uses Copilot to search company files with robust permission controls.

Microsoft is betting that the new Copilot will bridge this gap

As for how many of the 30 million paid seats are actually used, perhaps that is no longer the most critical issue. Because the new Copilot gives Microsoft a stronger reason for more users to actually open the app.

The new Copilot Home page integrates Chat and Cowork capabilities; Code allows users to create small apps using natural language; Autopilot can continue working even after the user logs out; Word, Excel, and PowerPoint are also integrated into the Copilot app.

Microsoft employee defends Copilot: The impression that nobody uses it comes from the San Francisco tech bubble

To be frank, compared with Copilot, which was long mocked as "Clippy 2.0," the product positioning Microsoft has proposed this time is much bigger.

What Bustamante wanted to express is that there are indeed people using Copilot to do real work, but they are not the ones discussing it on X every day.

And the new all-in-one Copilot super app that Nadella introduced is Microsoft's attempt to get more people to actually do that, whether or not they are in the San Francisco tech bubble.

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry